Yousaf Editing Advice

[dlowwa]

any better? Dust spots fixed? Sharpened enough? Also tried to fix a silhouette.

Both have issues with (lack of) contrast and sharpening.

[yousaf]

Both have issues with (lack of) contrast and sharpening.

both should be sharpened more ?

[dlowwa]

both should be sharpened more ?

Correct.

[yousaf]

Any better ? Added contrast using curves. Sharpned.
another Qatari requesting pre-screening as silhouette.

Sharpening improved?

[dlowwa]

Any better ? Added contrast using curves. Sharpned.

Contrast ok, but badly oversharepend. Will not comment on this one any more.

another Qatari requesting pre-screening as silhouette.

Likely a contrast rejection. Silhouette doesn't add anything to the shot.

Sharpening improved?

Blurry, oversharpened, noisy. Will not comment on this one any more.

[yousaf]

Contrast ok, but badly oversharepend. Will not comment on this one any more.



Likely a contrast rejection. Silhouette doesn't add anything to the shot.



Blurry, oversharpened, noisy. Will not comment on this one any more.

Thanks. I know some times I overdo it. Please take it lightly.
This must be Backlit, but does the bird count as obstruction?

[yousaf]

This is another angle of the same aircraft with better editing, hopefully.

[dlowwa]

This must be Backlit, but does the bird count as obstruction?

No.

[yousaf]

Followed guideline loosely.Please comment on any issues

Which one I should choose?

[dlowwa]

Followed guideline loosely.Please comment on any issues

Which one I should choose?

These would be rejected for similar.

[yousaf]

These would be rejected for similar.

I would be using only one of these, which one I should use?

[LX-A343]

I would be using only one of these, which one I should use?

This is up to you to decide.

[yousaf]

This is up to you to decide.

Any one of these can be accepted?

[dlowwa]

Any one of these can be accepted?

I think you're missing the point. We're not going to pick which one from a sequence of similar images for you. You choose which one, and we can comment.

[yousaf]

I will choose this at this resolution. Please comment on any issues with it.



Does this Photo qualify as Hot ? A40-OVG This was taken in really bad weather.