Jordan Louie - Editing Advise

[Jordan Louie]

Hi could I get these prescreened please? Thanks for your time.

-Jordan

[dlowwa]

Hi could I get these prescreened please? Thanks for your time.
[ATTACH=CONFIG]15445[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]15446[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]15447[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]15448[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]15449[/ATTACH]
-Jordan

Images already in the queue will not be prescreened by crew.

[Jordan Louie]

Images already in the queue will not be prescreened by crew.

Okay pics are out of queue.

[dlowwa]

Hi could I get these prescreened please? Thanks for your time.
[ATTACH=CONFIG]15445[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]15446[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]15447[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]15448[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]15449[/ATTACH]
-Jordan

1. soft
2. contrast (low)
3. heat haze, contrast
4. soft/blurry, contrast, dirty
5. dirty

[Jordan Louie]

5. dirty

Is this better for the WestJet?

Thanks, Jordan

[dlowwa]

Is this better for the WestJet?
[ATTACH=CONFIG]15483[/ATTACH]
Thanks, Jordan

Some compression visible on that one, and still a dust spot top-center of frame.

[Jordan Louie]

Some compression visible on that one, and still a dust spot top-center of frame.

Okay I tried to clean up all of the dust spots. Is the compression bad enough to get a rejection now?

Thanks, Jordan

[dlowwa]

Okay I tried to clean up all of the dust spots. Is the compression bad enough to get a rejection now?
[ATTACH=CONFIG]15501[/ATTACH]
Thanks, Jordan

Don't think so, but it does seem a bit soft.

[Jordan Louie]

Don't think so, but it does seem a bit soft.

Okay, thanks for the advice.
Just as a general question, this is a histogram for a picture. Would clipped highlights like this cause a rejection? Also would the lack of shadows on the left automatically cause a contrast rejection for all pictures?

Thanks, Jordan

[dlowwa]

Okay, thanks for the advice.
Just as a general question, this is a histogram for a picture. Would clipped highlights like this cause a rejection? Also would the lack of shadows on the left automatically cause a contrast rejection for all pictures?
[ATTACH=CONFIG]15606[/ATTACH]
Thanks, Jordan

The histogram above shows what would likely be a rejection for overexposure, yes. As for contrast, the histogram is a guide, but screening decisions are not based on it.

[Jordan Louie]

The histogram above shows what would likely be a rejection for overexposure, yes. As for contrast, the histogram is a guide, but screening decisions are not based on it.

Okay thanks for the info
-Jordan

[Jordan Louie]

Hi, I was wondering if there was too much compression on both of these images and if the Horizon Dash 8 is soft or not.


-Thanks, Jordan

[dlowwa]

Hi, I was wondering if there was too much compression on both of these images and if the Horizon Dash 8 is soft or not.
[ATTACH=CONFIG]15715[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH=CONFIG]15716[/ATTACH]
-Thanks, Jordan

Compression should not be an issue, but contrast, overprocessing, noise, and softness would be.

[Jordan Louie]

Compression should not be an issue, but contrast, overprocessing, noise, and softness would be.

Okay, thanks. How are the pictures overprocessed?

[dlowwa]

Okay, thanks. How are the pictures overprocessed?

Editing halos are visible.