Oh yeah, I know, thanks. I just want to hear the original audio. I also want to see an animation of the accident based on the FDR. NTSB does it, the Russians do it sometimes, so hopefully so will BEA.
I agree on the documentary. The idea is great, but they have missed on some parts. Also, their cockpit recreation doesn't have the turbulence and roll oscillations, like NOVA/BBC's Mystery of AF447 documentary. I get pissed off when they talk about the "plummeting temperature causing the pitots to ice". Even these pilots knew the weather was WARM and talked about it. They also knew about losing the speeds. Again, can't figure out if they had false altitude readings and a failed VS, this seems to be coming from an Air France pilot. One of the most important part from the CVR they should have included is Robert's "according to this you're climbing, according to all three you're climbing". So I can't figure the whole point of the documentary, though the conclusions at the end are right. I guess we'll have to wait for Mayday's take, it should be coming out in a few months.
So basically you feel Bonin was trying to fly over a turbulent part of the storm?
I agree on the documentary. The idea is great, but they have missed on some parts. Also, their cockpit recreation doesn't have the turbulence and roll oscillations, like NOVA/BBC's Mystery of AF447 documentary. I get pissed off when they talk about the "plummeting temperature causing the pitots to ice". Even these pilots knew the weather was WARM and talked about it. They also knew about losing the speeds. Again, can't figure out if they had false altitude readings and a failed VS, this seems to be coming from an Air France pilot. One of the most important part from the CVR they should have included is Robert's "according to this you're climbing, according to all three you're climbing". So I can't figure the whole point of the documentary, though the conclusions at the end are right. I guess we'll have to wait for Mayday's take, it should be coming out in a few months.
So basically you feel Bonin was trying to fly over a turbulent part of the storm?
Comment