Steve Worner - prescreening request / editing advice

[steveworner]

Thank you,

Does this version improve things enough?

[dlowwa]

Thank you,

Does this version improve things enough?

Improved yes. Enough, couldn't promise.

[steveworner]

Thank you.

I had a rejection for 'soft' on an image. I've given a re-sharpen. Would this version make the cut?

[dlowwa]

Thank you.

I had a rejection for 'soft' on an image. I've given a re-sharpen. Would this version make the cut?

I would reject this for soft. Left side is soft.

[steveworner]

Thank you,

Would this image from the same sequence (a couple of frames later) make the cut?

[dlowwa]

Thank you,

Would this image from the same sequence (a couple of frames later) make the cut?

Also soft left side.

[steveworner]

Thank you,

I've found a third image from the sequence that looks okay so I'll see how that goes.

Can I get an opinion on this image? it's cropped to 1:1 and I'm not sure if JP have a policy on that.

[dlowwa]

Thank you,

I've found a third image from the sequence that looks okay so I'll see how that goes.

Can I get an opinion on this image? it's cropped to 1:1 and I'm not sure if JP have a policy on that.

All images must be within the 4:3 - 16:9 range.

[steveworner]

Thank you, I've been able to crop it down to a 16:11 format, which I think is within JP requirements.

Would this version make the cut quality-wise?

[dlowwa]

Thank you, I've been able to crop it down to a 16:11 format, which I think is within JP requirements.

Would this version make the cut quality-wise?

Soft, and images that only show the non-lit side of the aircraft tend not to do well in screening.

[steveworner]

Thank you,

Can I get feedback on these two images?

[dlowwa]

Thank you,

Can I get feedback on these two images?

Borderline soft.

[steveworner]

Thank you,

Can I get an opinion on this image?

[dlowwa]

Thank you,

Can I get an opinion on this image?

Quality-wise, only issue I see is some purple fringing/CA. Crop is subjective. Probably ok, but it's a bit awkward.